Honest Review:
Deputy

Convenient timekeeping and helpful AI-powered auto-scheduling with break compliance, but glitches and bugs negatively affect UX

Written by Asim Qureshi
By Asim Qureshi, CEO Jibble
As a CEO of a time tracking software company I need to know what my competitors are up to. That means my team and I are often researching about and/or playing around with their products, you know, it’s part of the job. Here, I share my findings of that research, giving credit to those competitors where credit is due and being honest about which products I believe you really need to avoid. And so, there you have it, this review, and in it, I try to be honest, fair, and insightful. I hope it helps you make the right decision…

This review covers:

Overview

Deputy is a cloud-based solution for time tracking and productivity enhancement developed and presented by Deputechnologies. It touts to simplify employee scheduling, streamline timesheets and cut down on HR processes. With glowing reviews across many platforms and a whopping userbase of 365k+ workspaces globally, it’s fair to say they do deliver on their promises.

Aside from time tracking, Deputy is also intended as an all-in-one solution for various business needs such as shift scheduling, project and task management, PTO management, performance monitoring, team communication, and break management that is compliant with local and federal break legislation. 

Deputy offers a web app for desktop users, mobile apps of both Android and iOS, and users can also set-up a dedicated kiosk which simplifies time tracking processes for on-site workers. 

Some of the things that make Deputy shine are its touchless facial recognition feature for clocking in and timesheet verification, accurate and real-time digital timesheets with automatic wage calculation, GPS location stamps and geofencing and dynamic and actionable reporting to review and compare worked hours and profits.

However, Deputy has its share of challenges as well. It can be glitchy and slow at times, and there is a significant lag in grabbing, starting, and ending shifts. Users can’t deny a shift request without changing the shift settings or deleting and reposting. Timesheets can take a while to update, and overall the platform could be a bit more intuitive to use, searching for everything can be a pain. The mobile app can also be slow and glitchy, causing delays in clocking in and accessing data.

Now, before we make any conclusions, it’s only fair to closely examine what Deputy has to offer. So, without further ado, let’s dive right in!

Representation of employee's dashboard

What Do Users Like About Deputy?

  • Touchless facial recognition
  • Powerful scheduling tools
  • Dynamic employee engagement

What Don't Users Like About Deputy?

  • Glitchy and slow performance
  • Poor mobile app
  • Lack of customization

What Pricing Plans Does Deputy Offer?

Deputy has four paid plans and a seasonal plan, each with a specific target, as well as a free trial period and discounts. Let’s take a closer look:

Scheduling Plan

The Deputy Scheduling Plan is designed for businesses that need a better way to create and manage schedules and communicate with their team.

At $4.50 per user per month, businesses get unlimited shifts per month, employee scheduling, auto-scheduling, POS integration, PTO & leave management. They also get the news feed, tasking, access to their open API, dashboard, meal & rest break planning, demand planning, SMS & email notifications, availability management, shift swap and find replacement, and users can creat schedule templates.

Time and Attendance Plan

The Deputy Time and Attendance Plan is intended for businesses that need to track attendance and seamlessly export timesheets to payroll. 

For $4.50 per user per month, this plan gives businesses access all the Scheduling plan features plus unlimited timesheets per month, payroll integration, performance & journaling, biometric and geolocation activated time clock and custom timesheet fields.

Premium Plan

The Deputy Premium Plan addresses both the Scheduling and Time and Attendance targets and adds reporting into the mix.

Priced at $6 per user per month, this plan has all the features of both Scheduling and Time and Attendance, plus reporting and the Shift Pulse™ employee engagement feature.

Enterprise Plan

The Deputy Enterprise Plan is for organizations with more than 250 members and complex custom configuration needs.

This plan has all the Premium features, plus SSO, advanced demand planning, advanced reporting and analytics, custom-built pay rates, custom implementation, custom roles & permissions, custom organization structure, dedicated enterprise support, location & department level procedures, and training matrix. 

Pricing for this plan is custom, and prospective users must contact Deputy directly for a quote. 

Flexi Weekly Plan

The Deputy Flexi Weekly Plan is designed for seasonal businesses that need all the features of the Premium Plan and the flexibility to pay only $2.50 per active user per week, and $0.50 per inactive user per week.

What are the Standout Features of Deputy?

1. Deputy Auto-Scheduling

Deputy offers cutting-edge auto-scheduling assisted by AI that eliminates the need to build schedules shift by shift. This AI-powered feature creates schedules based on data analytics such as sales, foot traffic, season, occasions, and more. What I love about this feature is that it takes the guesswork and agony out of scheduling and ensures that schedules are optimized with the most suitable workers in every shift.

Users can specify parameters and considerations for the auto-scheduling feature to follow, such as accurate labor forecasting for priorities like cost and shift equality, or even match preferences to create rosters that best match business needs. 

Shift lengths, start times, and other preferences can also be factored in to ensure that employees are kept happy and productive. All of these considerations can be specified in the initial setup and then reflected in custom schedule structures at the click of a button with Auto-Fill. 

Best of all, Deputy’s auto-scheduling feature also takes legal compliance with wage and work hours laws into consideration, so employers have a guard against legal violations that endanger businesses.

 

2. Deputy Employee Break Compliance

Breaks are an essential part of the work day, as they allow employees to devote a bit of time for their needs and for rest so they can be at 100% on the hours that they’re actively working. Mandatory breaks for meals and rest are covered by the law, and their lengths and frequency are dictated by the United States Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division. The states of New York, Washington, Massachusetts, Oregon, and California have tougher restrictions than most. For such a crucial aspect of work, ensuring compliance to avoid potentially catastrophic and costly violations is difficult — if not totally impossible — with paper-based or manual scheduling.

Luckily, Deputy has break planning and compliance functionality across all devices that enable businesses to create compliant schedules and manage both paid and unpaid meal and rest breaks. This is a very valuable tool that eliminates the employer’s worry about compliance with break legalities by harnessing the power of AI to create schedules that factor in complicated workplace regulations with ease.

With this feature, employers can be confident about scheduling multiple breaks in a single shift without sacrificing coverage, prevent non-compliant early clock-in and early break returns, have attestation showing compliance and all break details for company records, and ensure that employees are getting the downtime they need to ensure optimum performance.

What I also love about this feature is that it forces employees to really take some time for themselves during the workday. It can be very easy to forget to eat or rest when fully immersed in work, and that can have serious implications on both physical and mental health. Deputy’s break compliance helps take care of that, and hopefully, promote healthier practices in the workplace.

Visualising employee's meal and rest break schedule

4. Deputy Payroll Integrations

The data captured by the Deputy employee time clock are automatically translated into timesheets that can be reviewed and verified with GPS location stamping and facial recognition and then approved individually or in bulk. 

These accurate and verified timesheets cut down on admin tasks by automatically calculating the various pay rates for every employee, job, and location, including overtime and penalty, and can be exported to any of the many Deputy third-party payroll integrations with just one click. 

Deputy integrates with various payroll software to save time and provide even deeper insight into captured work hours data. These include the usual suspects such as Xero, QuickBooks Online, ADP, MYOB, Access WageEasy, and more. 

Aside from payroll software, Deputy also integrates with point of sales, human resources, storage, sales forecasting, financial wellness, and other software to vastly improve its usability and functionalities. Plus, its integration with Zapier opens up even more possibilities.

Now, while I’m truly impressed by the wealth of integrations offered by Deputy it needs to work on their seamlessness. Exporting to Xero can be problematic at times, and integrating with financial apps can be quite difficult. Plus, it also doesn’t offer much in the way of customization so users have to make do with what’s available. 

Screen visualizing Deputy's integration with OnPay

Selected Positive User Feedback: 

  • “I like the schedule page on Deputy. I like that shifts and days are laid out in a neat grid, and that you can see unavailablity/time off when working on a schedule. I also, like the overall look of Deputy, it is very clean.” – Verified User in Consumer Services (Source G2)
  • “One of the best things about Deputy is its user-friendly interface, which makes scheduling, time tracking, and shift management seamless. It also offers great flexibility with real-time updates and easy communication, helping to reduce admin time and improve overall efficiency.” – Nupur M. (Source G2)
  • “Improved communciation with staff, employees appreciate app’s ease of use and the ability to check their schedules. Drastically reduced errors in rostering. Timesheet system is of great help for payroll.” – Verified User in Hospital & Health Care (Source G2)
  • “Scheduling tool is phenomenal, I love the way it moves right over to the timesheet and is easy to use for my team members. The timeclock is simple and easy to install. We also love the tasks app and the integration with our payroll software.” – Shelly M. (Source G2)
  • “This is a great tool for scheduling that prevents confusion and makes the workplace feel more fair and interconnected.” – Derek J. (Source Capterra)

Selected Negative User Feedback: 

  • “It has been noted by employees that the Deputy app is slow or gets stuck when starting or ending shift (especially when ending shift)” – Lynne S. (Source Capterra)
  • “There is no way to deny a shift request without changing the shift settings or deleting and reposting.” – Kevin L. (Source G2)
  • “Sometimes it takes awhile to update people’s timesheets” – Faith P. (Source G2)
  • “It could be a little more intuitive to use. You often have to search for what you are looking for.” – Verified User in Restaurantw (Source G2) 
  • “One downside of Deputy is that the mobile app can occasionally be glitchy, causing delays in clocking in or accessing schedules. Additionally, some advanced features might require a bit of a learning curve for new users” – Nupur M. (Source G2)

    What are Deputy's Review Ratings from Review Sites?


    (As of October 2024)

    • Capterra: 4.6/5
    • Play Store: 4.7/5
    • Google Play: 4.7/5
    • G2: 4.6/5
    • GetApp: 4.6/5
    • Software Advice: 4.6/5
    • TrustRadius: 8.6/10 

    What's My Final Verdict on Deputy?

    Deputy is a very good solution for businesses that need a complete admin and HR tool to increase productivity and streamline processes. In the course of research for this review, I’ve found out that it is an efficient second in command that when utilized properly, delivers amazing results. It stands out as a highly capable and versatile solution for businesses aiming to streamline their workforce management processes. 

    With its suite of features, including AI-powered auto-scheduling, legal break compliance, touchless facial recognition for clock-ins, and more, Deputy effectively addresses the diverse needs of modern businesses. 

    These tools not only enhance operational efficiency but also help businesses maintain compliance with labor laws, making it a valuable asset for organizations of all sizes. Its affordability and tiered pricing plans offer flexibility, accommodating businesses from small startups to large enterprises with unique needs.

    That said, Deputy is not without its limitations. Users have highlighted occasional glitches, a lack of customization options, and a subpar mobile app experience, the app can sometimes be slow and unreliable. 

    These issues, while not deal-breakers, underscore areas where the platform could improve to better serve its user base. Enhancements in performance, user experience, and integration seamlessness would also further solidify Deputy’s standing as a top-tier workforce management solution.

    For businesses willing to navigate these relatively minor drawbacks, Deputy offers great value. It combines functionality, and compliance into one package, empowering organizations to optimize their operations, improve employee satisfaction, and save time.