How Trump’s Second Term Could Transform U.S. Labor Laws

The return of Donald Trump to the White House in 2025 has sent shockwaves through the nation, provoking a mix of anticipation and apprehension. From a legal standpoint, serious concern is expressed over the trajectory that U.S. labor law and regulations about worker rights will likely take under this administration. Based on the significant changes implemented during his first term and the messages conveyed during his campaign, it is clear that Trump’s second term could significantly weaken worker protections, labor rights, and workplace safety.

First Term Revisited: A Prelude to Deregulation

During his first term from 2017 to 2021, Trump openly prioritized the interests of employers, often at the direct expense of American workers. One of the most harmful actions taken was the revision of overtime rules. By raising the salary threshold for overtime eligibility to only $35,568 annually—well below inflation-adjusted levels—the administration effectively deprived millions of workers of the overtime pay they were entitled to. This decision is estimated to have cost workers over $1 billion in lost wages.

Additionally, the Trump administration narrowed the definition of “employer,” allowing companies to distance themselves from the actions of subcontractors and franchisees. This change severely limited protections for workers, particularly those in vulnerable positions such as gig workers, janitors, and delivery personnel. By complicating the process of holding parent companies accountable, workers faced increasing challenges in negotiating wages and securing fair working conditions.

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) also struggled under Trump’s leadership. The agency saw its number of inspectors drop to the lowest level in U.S. history, significantly weakening its ability to enforce workplace safety regulations. Penalties for companies that failed to report OSHA violations were reduced, and public notices of legal violations were limited, despite evidence showing that transparency encourages compliance. This enforcement relaxation sent employers a message that they could disregard safety regulations with minimal repercussions, putting countless workers at risk.

Anticipated Changes in the Second Term: Escalating the Assault on Worker Rights

Considering Trump’s history and recent comments, it is essential to prepare for a stronger attack on labor protections in his potential second term.

1. Rollback of Overtime Pay Eligibility

The Biden administration has made significant progress by raising the overtime pay eligibility threshold to $43,888, with a planned increase to $58,656 set for January 1, 2025. This policy aims to ensure that millions more salaried employees receive fair compensation for the extra hours they work. Unfortunately, there are concerns that Trump may halt this increase or revert to his previous threshold of $35,568, which would deny workers their hard-earned wages and disproportionately impact low- to middle-income employees.

2. Erosion of Labor Unions and Collective Bargaining

Trump’s admiration for figures like Elon Musk, who has demonstrated a readiness to confront and even dismiss striking workers, highlights his antagonistic position toward labor unions. We can expect policies that will further weaken unions, such as denying union membership to private university students and reclassifying employees to exclude gig workers from collective bargaining rights. These actions will disenfranchise workers and significantly shift the balance of power in favor of employers.

3. Weakening of Child Labor Protections

There are concerning signs that the administration may reduce penalties for violations of child labor laws and potentially permit minors to work in hazardous jobs with parental consent. As instances of child labor violations and injuries continue to increase, any effort to weaken these protections is not only regressive but also morally wrong.

4. Deregulation at the Expense of Workplace Safety

We can expect a continued trend of understaffing at key regulatory agencies like OSHA, which will delay the implementation of workplace protections against environmental hazards and health risks. This push for deregulation endangers workers’ lives, all in the name of reducing burdens on businesses.

5. Stagnation of Minimum Wage and Elimination of Taxes on Tips and Overtime

Trump’s earlier threat to veto any increase in the federal minimum wage, which currently stands at a low $7.25 per hour, indicates that workers should not anticipate any relief from wage stagnation. Although eliminating taxes on tips and overtime pay may seem advantageous at first glance, it could result in reduced tax revenue for vital public services. It might encourage employers to exploit wage structures to their benefit.

A Critical Juncture for American Workers

Criticism of Trump’s past actions and anticipated moves regarding labor law and workers is unavoidable. It is important to emphasize that these expected policies not only undermine established labor regulations but also violate fundamental principles of fairness and justice in the workplace. Prioritizing employer interests over employee well-being creates a dangerous environment where exploitation can thrive without restraint.

The erosion of labor protections weakens the foundations that ensure safe, equitable, and dignified working conditions. Workers may face limited options for addressing unfair practices, wage theft, and hazardous work environments. The long-term consequences could include increased income inequality, a demoralized workforce, and a decline in overall economic productivity due to reduced consumer spending power.

Conclusion: The Imperative for Vigilance and Advocacy

In light of these potential developments, workers, unions, and advocates must remain vigilant and proactive. Legal challenges may become necessary to contest policies that violate labor rights and endanger workers. Moreover, employers genuinely committed to ethical practices should resist the temptation to exploit deregulation for short-term gains, recognizing that a satisfied and secure workforce is crucial for sustainable success.

The approach to labor laws under a second Trump administration poses a significant threat to the hard-won rights of American workers. This situation is not merely a policy shift; it is a fundamental challenge to the values of fairness and protection that underpin the labor system. Society must question whether the push for deregulation and profit justifies the human cost. From a legal and moral standpoint, the answer should be a resounding no.

Related News:

Bank of America raises minimum wage to US$24 per hour in U.S. locations

Is tip exemption from income taxes a possibility in the US?

91% of California service sector workers saw labor violations in 2023

U.S. DOL Recovers US$152K in overtime wages for Bronx medical employees

New York becomes first state to offer paid prenatal personal leave