Guide to Firing Employees in New York for Employers

April 11th 2024

Employee termination is one of the most challenging responsibilities for employers. It is important to properly navigate the process of termination to avoid legal challenges, maintain workplace morale and prevent damage to the company reputation. In New York there are stringent laws and policies in place to protect the rights of employees and prevent discriminatory actions, and so employers need to take care to comply with these requirements. This guide offers employers detailed information about the termination process, including best practices and legal responsibilities to bear in mind.

This Guide Covers

What Does Firing an Employee Involve?
Differentiating between Firing, Layoffs, and Resignations in New York
Why the Termination Process Matters in New York
Termination Laws in New York: What You Need to Know
Legal Implications of Wrongful Termination in New York
Required Documents for Employers and Terminated Employees in New York
Who is Responsible for Terminating in New York?
How Long Should the Termination Process Last in New York?
How Can You Prepare for Termination in New York?
Steps for a Respectful Termination Process in New York
Post-Termination: What Happens Next?
Legal Considerations During Termination in New York
Bonus: Best Practices for Reducing Litigation Risks in New York

What Does Firing an Employee Involve?

Firing or terminating an employee is the process whereby a company ends the employment relationship between itself and a staff member or group of employees. This decision can be driven by various factors including, but not limited to, performance issues, misconduct, redundancy, or business closure.

Differentiating between Firing, Layoffs, and Resignations in New York

In the context of employment terminations, it is crucial for employers, especially those in New York, to understand the differences between firing, layoffs, and resignations. Each scenario has distinct implications for both the employee and employer and handling them appropriately is essential to maintain a fair workplace and comply with legal standards within the state.

Firing in New York

The firing of an employee usually occurs as a result of an individual’s unsatisfactory performance or actions at work. There are numerous issues which lead to an employee being fired, including:

  • Employee conduct which goes against company values.
  • Employee conduct which has a negative impact on the working environment.
  • Poor performance and low productivity levels, not meeting company standards.
  • A lack of productivity and low performance levels that do not meet the company standards.
  • Violation of company rules and policies.
  • Misconduct such as harassment, fraud or breaches of confidentiality.
  • Engaging in illegal activity outside of work.

New York is an “at-will” employment state; therefore, employers have the right to fire employees for any reason, or no reason at all, at any time, without prior notice. However, there are exceptions to this, and employers must pay close attention to state and federal employment laws, as well as employment contracts or collective bargaining agreements which stipulate termination requirements. Unlawful actions and the breaching of policies can result in wrongful termination lawsuits against an employer. Wrongful termination in New York also includes the firing of an employee for discriminatory reasons or for retaliation against an individual for legally reporting employer violations of the law. To avoid legal consequences, it is essential for employers to be aware of such exceptions.

Layoffs in New York

When an employee is laid off in New York, it is not due to any fault of their own, unlike firing. Layoffs take place when a company needs to reduce its workforce for various reasons, including:

  • The restructuring or organising of the company, leading to redundant positions.
  • The need to implement cost-cutting measures, such as reducing the workforce, due to economic hardships.
  • Mergers or acquisitions which lead to job duplication, requiring a reduction in the workforce.
  • The closure of certain business areas or the whole company.

Depending on the situation, layoffs can be either temporary or permanent. In some cases, if the circumstances of the company improve, laid-off employees may be rehired. In New York, employers must adhere to the federal Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act during the termination process. The WARN Act and New York laws require all employers who meet the eligibility criteria to give advanced notice to employees of layoffs and plant closures. Employers who fail to provide notice will be liable to civil penalties and the payment of back wages and benefits.

Resignations in New York

Resignations are different to firings and layoffs, as in these cases it is the employee who voluntarily terminates employment. Resignations occur for a wide range of personal and professional reasons, including:

  • Personal or family medical issues.
  • Relocation to a different area.
  • A job offer from another company.
  • Dissatisfaction with the current workplace.
  • Change of career path.

“At-will” employment also allows employees to resign for any reason and at any time. Therefore, in New York, employees do not have to give advanced notice of their resignation. However, it is good practice to give a notice period (usually two weeks) to the employer, to provide time for them to find a replacement or to make the necessary adjustments to the team. Giving advanced notice can also help to ensure that employment ends on amicable terms, which is important for an employee looking to gain a reference.

For all termination situations in New York, whether initiated by the employer or employee, New York Labor Law § 195(6) requires written notice to be provided no later than 5 working days after the date of termination. The notice must state the date of termination and the date that any employee benefits will cease.

Additionally, it is essential that employers respect employee rights and comply with both New York and federal laws during the termination process. An example would be delivering the final paycheck on time.

In New York, all employers are required to provide continuation of health insurance for terminated employees through the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) or New York’s Mini-COBRA programme. Employers with more than 20 employees must offer the continuation of COBRA health insurance, regardless of whether the termination was voluntary or involuntary. Smaller employers, with less than 20 workers, must offer the continuation of health insurance under the New York Mini-COBRA programme. Terminated employees can receive insurance with COBRA for 18 months. Under the New York Mini-COBRA, insurance coverage lasts for 36 months. Those with COBRA coverage are also able to receive an extra 18 months under the New York state law once their original 18 months has ended.

Moreover, the way an employer conducts terminations is crucial. Employers should be as transparent as possible with the reason for terminations and offer transition assistance to employees, such as job search assistance and outplacement services (career programmes for fired or laid off employees). The working environment and morale of remaining employees can be significantly impacted by employee terminations; therefore, it is crucial to ensure they are smooth and respectful. The reputation and public image of a company can also be affected if it is known to handle terminations badly. Finally, maintaining a positive relationship with departing employees can allow for potential rehiring in the future, developing a lasting professional network.

It is key for employers in New York to fully understand the differences between firing, layoffs and resignations. This allows for the appropriate handling of terminations, in line with labor laws and policies, whilst maintaining a respectful company culture and workplace environment.

Why the Termination Process Matters in New York

The termination process in New York is particularly crucial due to the state’s stringent labor laws and the heightened focus on employee rights. Here’s why the termination process matters.

  • Legal Compliance: Employers must comply with both State and federal labor laws in New York, which tend to favour employee rights. There are laws covering a range of employment aspects, including wage, hour and paycheck policies, as well as discrimination and harassment laws. Failure to comply with the law during the termination process can result in legal repercussions for the company.
  • Protection Against Wrongful Termination Claims: Employers need to practice caution when terminating employees due to the strict laws against retaliation, discrimination and harassment in New York. Employers can face wrongful termination claims for discrimination, breach of contract, retaliation for refusing to engage in illegal activity, retaliation for lawful whistleblowing or violation of protected job leave and employee rights. Therefore, the implementation of a fair termination process and thorough documentation of the reasons for termination are essential to mitigate the risk of claims.  
  • Maintaining Workplace Morale: A poorly handled termination process can lead to demoralised staff, decreased employee engagement and increased employee turnover. Conversely, a transparent and fair termination process can bolster a positive work environment and feelings of trust and security. Employers must be aware of how their actions can impact morale and proceed with caution.
  • Upholding Company Reputation: The manner in which a company conducts terminations can affect its reputation and public image. Mishandled terminations can be damaging, demonstrating poor company values, deterring top talent and reducing the customer base. Employment practices, such as termination procedures, can have a significant impacts on business success.
  • Ensuring Smooth Operational Transition: Terminations can disrupt normal business operations and productivity.  An employer should properly manage this process by planning how to reallocate the workload of the departing employee and how to restructure the team. A smooth transition process maintains efficiency and minimises disruptions to business practices.
  • Reducing Financial Risks: Unlawful termination procedures can lead to legal charges and settlements. If employers implement and follow proper processes, costly litigation can be prevented.
  • Employee Rights and Final Pay: New York has specific laws in regard to employee rights, such as final paycheck rules. A final paycheck must be paid by the next regular payday, at the latest. Any unused paid vacation days must also be paid when employment is terminated, unless stated otherwise in a contract. If employers violate these labor laws during the termination process, they may face penalties.
  • Ethical Considerations: Ethical standards are important for employers to consider. In New York, all employees are required to be treated ethically and high standards are upheld in this regard. It is important for employers to be fair and respectful during the termination process. The actions of the employer reflects on the overall culture and values of the company.

Termination Laws in New York: What You Need to Know

Laws Regarding Termination of On-Site Employees in New York

  • New York Human Rights Law (NYHRL): The New York Human Rights Law, or NYHRL for short, is a State anti-discrimination statute, prohibiting discrimination based on specific protected classes in employment and other areas. Under this law, every citizen has the right to equal opportunity. Protected classes include race, religion, disability, nationality, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, military status, sex, age, marital status, predisposing genetic characteristics, status as a victim of domestic violence and arrest or conviction record. In New York City, it is also illegal to discriminate against employees based on immigration or citizenship status, sexual and reproductive health decisions, employment status, credit history or caregiver status. In addition, it is against the law to discriminate against an employee for engaging in legal activities outside of work, including political activities, legal use of consumable products and legal recreational activities. An employer may face a wrongful termination claim or lawsuit for any of these discriminatory actions highlighted by the NYHRL. If violations have occurred, employers may be required to reinstate the employee, to pay for legal costs and to pay damages such as back pay, lost benefits and damages for emotional suffering. For employers, it is crucial to follow the law and to record all performance reviews and legitimate business reasons resulting in the termination of an employee.
  • New York Labor Law Section 740: Section 740 of the New York Labor Laws prohibits employers from firing or retaliating against an employee for lawfully raising concerns to a supervisor or governmental agency about illegal activity which could pose a threat to the safety and health of the public. It is also forbidden to terminate employees who refuse to participate in such unlawful activity or those who assist investigations into such conduct. If an employer fires a worker for blowing the whistle, they may face legal action. Employers found to have violated employee rights will be required to reinstate the employee, provide compensation for lost wages and benefits and pay the legal fees and costs.
  • The New York State Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act: The New York State WARN Act requires employers with 50 or more full-time employees to provide notice 90 days before mass layoffs, plant closures or relocation. The employer must provide notice to all affected employees, employee representatives, the Local Workforce Development Board (LWDB), the chief elected official of local government where the site is located, the school district or districts where the site of employment is located and to all emergency services that support the area where the site is located. This law was established to protect employees from abrupt terminations, providing time to find alternative employment. If an employer violates this Act, they will be required to pay back wages and employee benefits in addition to civil penalties.
  • New York Labor Law 191: This labor law states that employers are required to deliver the final paycheck to a terminated employee by the next regular payday at the latest. The paycheck must be sent by mail, if so requested by the employee. In New York, employers are not obligated to provide paid vacation. However, any unused paid vacation time that has been allocated, must be paid by the employer at termination. This is unless the employment contract or company policies specifically state otherwise. Commissions are also classed as wages, therefore, employers should have agreements in place for payments when an employee is terminated. Labor law 191 applies to all departing employees, including those who have been fired, laid off or who have resigned.

Laws Regarding Termination of Remote Employees in New York

All workers, whether working remotely or on-site, are protected under both federal and state laws in New York. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and New York labor laws reinforce the employment laws for remote workers; they are entitled to the same pay, benefits and opportunities as onsite workers. Employers should be aware of the remote employees’ situation to ensure compliance with laws, as they might be working in jurisdictions with different, possibly more stringent, employment laws.

  • New York Human Rights Law (NYHRL): The NYHRL applies to all workers within New York, whether they are remote employees or working on-site. Employers must ensure they do not terminate remote employees for discriminatory reasons, otherwise they may be accused of wrongful termination and face litigation.
  • Telecommuting Agreements: If a telecommuting agreement is in place, it may contain specific stipulations for remote employees, such as termination procedures or notice periods. Employers are required to adhere to these agreements to avoid violating the contract and facing legal charges.
  • New York Labor Law 191: Employees are entitled to receive their final paycheck on or before the next regular payday after termination. The paycheck must be sent by mail, if so request by the employee. This statute does not discriminate based on whether an employee works on-site or remotely; the same time-frame is applicable for all workers.
  • Data Protection and Privacy Laws: Another consideration for employers when terminating remote employees, is the return and protection of sensitive company data. Employers should implement procedures and contractual agreements to secure data transfer and deletion from personal devices, in compliance with data protection laws.
  • Work-From-Home Equipment and Expense Reimbursement: Under New York Labor Law Section 198-C , employers are required to reimburse employees for work-related expenses if there is an agreement, such as in the employment contract or company policies. The failure of employers to comply with reimbursement agreements is considered a misdemeanor under state laws. Employers should make sure to have specific protocols for remote workers, outlining the requirements for the return of company equipment and reimbursements after termination. Such policies will help reduce misunderstandings and noncompliance. This is especially important with the increase in remote working.

In New York, the legal implications of wrongful termination can be extensive and complex, given the state’s robust employment laws and protections. Here’s a detailed look at these implications:

  • Violation of Anti-Discrimination Laws: New York has strict anti-discrimination laws in place, governed by the NYHRL. Discriminatory employee terminations violate this law and guilty employers will be required to reinstate or promote the employee. Additionally, employers may have to pay monetary damages including back wages, lost benefits, damages for emotional suffering, punitive damages and employee attorney fees. At the federal level, laws such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, reinforce protections against discrimination and invoke further liabilities.
  • Retaliation Claims: In New York, wrongful termination claims can be made by those who were terminated due to retaliation. Under New York Labor Law Section 740, the termination of an employee as retaliation for protected activities such as reporting a complaint, whistleblowing or participating in investigations, is unlawful. Employer retaliation can result in wrongful termination claims. Employers may be obligated to reinstate the individual or pay front pay whilst they find alternative employment, pay for lost wages and benefits, and pay for the legal fees and costs. Therefore, it is essential for employers to be aware of actions which constitute as wrongful termination. Litigation can be costly and damaging to internal morale and for the reputation of the company.
  • Constructive Dismissal: If an employee feels forced to resign due to intolerable working conditions created by their employer, this counts as constructive dismissal. The formulation of unbearable working conditions can be a more subtle form of employer retaliation against employees. Wrongful termination claims can be filed for the violation of working conditions and employee rights, resulting in constructive dismissal. The employer may be required to compensate wrongfully fired employees for lost wages and benefits, emotional damage, and the cost of legal fees.
  • Breach of Contract and Implied Contract Claims: New York is an “at-will” employment state, unless an employment contract states otherwise. If an employer violates the specifics of a contract, whether written, verbal, or implied, they may face wrongful termination allegations. When wrongful termination has occurred, an employee may be entitled to receive damages for breach of contract, lost wages, benefits and compensation for emotional suffering. Therefore, it is crucial for employers to ensure compliance with the terms and conditions of a contract before terminating an employee, to prevent costly litigation.
  • Violation of Public Policy: In New York, employees are protected from termination that violates clearly mandated public policy. This includes discharging an employee for refusing to participate in illegal activities, for serving jury service, participating in lawful recreational or political activities outside of work, joining or forming a union or for exercising a legal right. Employees may be awarded compensation and damages for the negative impact.
  • Financial Impact and Reputational Damage: In New York, wrongful termination claims can significantly impact both the finances and reputation of a company. Employers found to have unlawfully terminated an employee will need to pay for legal services, penalties and damages. These costs can add up. Lawsuits and allegation can also cause reputational damage to a company, with the potential to drive away consumers and top talent and harm business relationships.
  • Internal Impact on Employee Morale: Wrongful termination claims negatively impact the internal working environment. They can affect the morale and productivity of the remaining employees, creating a distrusting and insecure environment.

Required Documents for Employers and Terminated Employees in New York

Employers’ Requirements 

  • Employment Termination Letter: Under New York Labor Law 195(6), employers are required to provide employees with a written termination letter, stating the date of termination and the date of termination of benefits. The letter must be delivered no later than 5 days after employment termination. All departed employees, regardless of whether termination was voluntary or involuntary, must receive a letter, serving as an official record of the termination.
  • New York Department of Labor (DOL) Employment Record: Under 12 N.Y.C.R.R. § 472.8, all employers are required to inform departing employees of their right to file for unemployment benefits. The New York DOL employment record form, Form IA 12.3, must be provided by the employer upon termination.
  • Final Paycheck: Under New York Labor Law 191, employers are required to deliver the final paycheck to a terminated employee by the next regular payday, at the latest. The paycheck must be delivered by mail if so requested by the employee. The final paycheck must include all unpaid wages, commissions and unused paid vacation days, unless a written policy or employment contract states otherwise.
  • Health Insurance (COBRA) Notice: In New York, all employers are obligated to inform terminated employees of their right to continue to receive health insurance under COBRA (Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act) for 18 months, or New York’s Mini-COBRA programme for employers with less than 20 employees, lasting 36 months. Those who have reached the 18-month limit of COBRA coverage are able to receive coverage for another 18 months under the New York state law.

Terminated Employees’ Requirements 

  • Return of Company Property: Terminated employees are normally required to return all company property and equipment upon departure. Common items to return include employee cards, company documents, and IT equipment. There should be clauses in the employment contract outlining the procedures to follow, for both on-site and remote employees. It is strongly recommended to keep a record of returned items to avoid any misunderstandings or issues.
  • Acknowledgment of Final Paycheck and Documents: Employees should be aware that they may be required to sign termination forms and acknowledge the receipt of final wages after termination.
  • Exit Interview: It is common practice for employers to conduct an exit interview with employees upon termination. This provides an opportunity for departing employees to give honest feedback about the demands of the job and working environment, in a respectful manner.
  • Update of Personal Contact Information: Upon termination, it is important for employees to provide current and accurate contact information to ensure the receipt of any necessary documents and paychecks. Having up to date contact information may also be useful for any future communications.
  • Privacy and Non-Disclosure Agreements: It is essential for employees to understand the detailed conditions of any privacy or non-disclosure agreements and how termination affects these. In general, confidentiality agreements should be adhered to even after termination. It is advisable for terminated employees to practice caution, to mitigate the risks of legal repercussions for confidentiality violations.

Who is Responsible for Terminating in New York?

The process of employee termination in New York can be difficult, requiring sensitive handling. Managers, Human Resources (HR) representatives and legal counsel are those involved in employee terminations, each with specific tasks and responsibilities.

Role and Responsibilities of Human Resources 

One of the roles of HR is to handle the employee termination process. They are one of the key players and ensure that all actions and procedures comply with company policies. HR are responsible for making sure that all relevant information is properly documented, that meetings are recorded and that the reasons for termination are valid. They should inform managers of the appropriate termination procedures, guide employees through the exit process, prepare termination letters and benefits forms and check that the payroll team are ready to deliver the final paycheck on time.

It is also the responsibility of HR to provide terminated employees with information about available benefits. This includes unemployment benefits by filling in Form IA 12.3, and health insurance continuation through COBRA or the New York Mini-COBRA Laws.

It is the role of HR to ensure the termination process runs smoothly with respect and sensitivity.

Role and Responsibilities of Managers 

Managers have a more direct role in the termination process as they normally communicate the news of the termination to the employee. Managers are often the ones to have first identified the problem and notified HR. Before termination, managers should have held meetings or discussions with the employee, explaining the problem and allowing the employee to correct their actions. It is essential for managers to have carefully documented the entire process, including initial meetings, warnings and communication with HR. They must provide clear, lawful reasons for the termination, following company policies. Post-termination, managers also play a key role in breaking the news of the termination to remaining employees, reorganising the team, redistributing the tasks of the terminated employee and maintaining employee morale and a positive environment.

Role and Responsibilities of Legal Counsel

The role of the legal counsel is essential in reducing the risk of litigation and wrongful termination allegations. It is their responsibility to ensure that all aspects of the termination process and actions of the employer comply with state and federal laws and regulations. For more complex cases, for example allegations of discrimination, contractual disputes or mass layoffs, the role of the legal team is especially important. The legal team should inform managers and HR of the legal requirements to terminate an employee.

How Long Should the Termination Process Last in New York?

In New York, the duration of the employee termination process can vary greatly depending on the circumstances of each case. As an at-will employment state, employers in New York are able to terminate employees at any time, with or without cause and they are not required to provide notice. This can make employee termination seem like a quick process. However, it usually is more complex and requires careful handling.

The combination of employment contracts, collective bargaining agreements and stringent employment laws in New York, makes the process of employee termination complex and challenging at times. It is essential for employers to thoroughly document the entire process, to maintain clear communication and to be knowledgeable of state and federal labor laws.

For termination due to poor performance, employers are advised to keep records of all relevant communications, including performance evaluations where issues were raised, warnings and any efforts to assist the employee in making changes. Clear evidence and documentation is essential to reduce the risk of wrongful termination claims. Therefore, this process can take weeks or months.

Moreover, some companies have collective bargaining agreements with unions in place and detailed employment contracts outlining specific requirements for termination. For example, they may require a certain length of time for a termination notice period. It is crucial that employers follow the terms of contracts, often resulting in an extended termination process.

In complex cases involving allegations of employee misconduct, or claims of employer discrimination or harassment, those involved in the termination process must proceed with even greater care. In such situations, legal counsel will play an important role. The process may also require investigations. The termination process in complex or sensitive cases can be extended for a long time.

How Can You Prepare for Termination in New York?

Preparing for termination in New York involves a series of steps, including:

  • Understanding the Legal Grounds for Termination: The first step for employers is to ensure that the reason for employee termination is not discriminatory and is in compliance with employment law. It is prohibited in New York to terminate an employee due to race, sexual orientation, gender, age, religion, disability, and other protected categories. Moreover, it is unlawful to terminate employees for exercising their legal rights, such as taking medical leave, or for filing reports detailing employer misconduct or violations.
  • Reviewing Company Policies and Employee Agreement: Thoroughly review company policies and procedures regarding employee termination. Also check if there is an employment contract or a collective bargaining agreement in place for the individual. Employers are obligated to abide by contractual agreements and policies. Noncompliance can cause legal repercussions and impact the company reputation.
  • Documenting Performance and Conduct Issues: It is essential to document all performance issues and cases of misconduct as these are important for employee terminations and potential litigation. This includes keeping records of performance reviews, write-ups and disciplinary actions. Records of clear documentation and communication are extremely important if the company is accused of wrongful termination.
  • Planning the Termination Meeting: The news of the termination is usually delivered in a termination meeting which is carried out by a manager. When planning the meeting, it is important to organise a time and setting which allows for as much privacy as possible, enabling the employee to keep their dignity. It is normal procedure to have a HR member present in the meeting to assist with any potential problems and to ensure it runs smoothly and respectfully.
  • Communicating Effectively: Communication during the termination meeting must be respectful and clear. Employers should explain the reason for termination, with relevant documentation or evidence if needed. Professionalism needs to be upheld throughout and the manager should not resort to personal criticisms.
  • Preparing the Final Paycheck: After termination, employers in New York are required to deliver the final paycheck on or before the next regular payday. The paycheck must be mailed if the employee has requested this. All owed wages, commission and accrued paid vacation time should be included, unless specifically stated otherwise in a contract or policy. Ensure that the payroll department is ready to deliver the paycheck.
  • Preparing Final Documents and Benefits: It is the role of the manager or HR to provide the terminated employee with any resources about outplacement services and available benefits. This includes providing Form IA 12.3 for employees to claim unemployment benefits and to offer the continuation of health insurance under COBRA or the New York Mini-COBRA Programmes.
  • Handling Post-Termination Procedures: Post-termination, the manager should deliver the news of termination in a respectful manner and maintain the privacy of the departed employee. Restructuring and reorganisation of the team may also be necessary in addition to the reallocation of the employees workload.

Steps for a Respectful Termination Process in New York

It is important that the termination process remains as respectful as possible. This involves a number of steps:

  • Review Employment Policies and Legal Compliance: Before proceeding with the termination of an employee, thoroughly review the company policies and contractual obligations to make sure any actions will be lawful. Also review the relevant New York employment laws to ensure compliance. It is essential to fully comprehend the legal grounds for termination and to follow these guidelines. This will prevent legal repercussions and damage to the reputation of the company.
  • Document Performance Issues: Document and keep detailed records of all employee performance or conduct issues. It is important to include dates, specific incidents, warnings and corrective actions taken. There are strict laws in New York protecting employee rights, so it is crucial to have evidence demonstrating lawful reasons for the termination of an employee.
  • Plan the Termination Meeting Carefully: The termination meeting should be thoughtfully arranged and organised. It should be held in a private setting and scheduled at an appropriate time to be as respectful and to ensure as much privacy as possible. It is advisable to have a representative from HR present in the meeting to ensure everything proceeds in line with New York employment laws.
  • Deliver the Termination Notice with Empathy: Delivering the news of termination is a difficult and uncomfortable task. A professional and empathetic manner is required. When delivering the notice, the manager should be respectful whilst showing empathy and avoiding personal criticism. The manner in which an employee is terminated can impact the reputation of a company and the morale of the remaining workforce.
  • Explain the Termination Decision Clearly: During the termination meeting, clearly and objectively outline the factual reasons for termination. Have clear documentation and evidence on hand if needed. Clear communication of the reason for termination can help prevent misunderstandings and legal challenges.
  • Arrange Final Pay and Benefits Information: Terminated employees should be fully informed by the manager and HR of their rights and options going forwards. HR need to ensure that payroll are ready to send the final paycheck on or before the next regular payday, as specified in New York laws. The departing employee should be informed of available benefits and assistance, including the continuance of health insurance under COBRA or the New York’s Mini-COBRA laws. It is the obligation of the employer to provide the terminated employee with Form IA 12.3 so they can apply for unemployment benefits.
  • Offer Support for the Transition: The transition from being employed to unemployed can be challenging. Therefore, it is good practice for the terminated employee to be provided with assistance resources outlining outplacement services and unemployment benefits. Offering suitable support to departing employees can also improve the public image of a company.
  • Conduct a Professional and Private Exit: It is important to conduct the exit process as professionally and privately as possible. After the termination meeting it is important to continue to uphold the dignity of the departing employee by finding an exit route without an onlooking crowd. Arrangements for the return of company property should also be prepared.
  • Provide an Opportunity for an Exit Interview: Conducting an exit interview with the departing employee is also commonplace. This can be a potential space for the terminated employee to provide valuable feedback about the workplace. Mangers should use these insights, when appropriate, to improve employment practices and the work environment.
  • Communicate with Remaining Staff Appropriately: It is important to properly communicate to the remaining workforce about the termination. Communication needs to be direct whilst being respectful of the privacy of the departed employee. The remaining employees need to feel reassured and comfortable in their workplace and to be aware of any restructuring required. The handling of terminations as well as the communication to the team after the event, impacts morale and productivity, so it is key to address situations with an appropriate approach.
  • Evaluate the Termination Process for Future Improvement: Post-termination, it can be helpful to review the entire process to uncover areas where improvements are needed. It is good business practice to continually review and improve company standards and procedures.

Post-Termination: What Happens Next?

After termination, to ensure a smooth transition in line with New York laws, employers should follow a number of steps:

Firstly, the final paycheck needs to be delivered to the terminated employee no later than on the next regular payday. This must include all unpaid wages, commission and accrued paid vacation days, unless stated otherwise in a contract. The employer is also required to provide information about the continuation of COBRA or New York Mini-COBRA medical insurance and to give the Form IA 12.3 to the employee so they can receive unemployment benefits. It is the role of HR to handle the cessation of benefits for which the terminated employee is longer entitled.

Next, the employee needs to return all company property in their possession. In most cases, HR should make the arrangements for employees to return property, this is particularly important when dealing with remote employees. Providing a checklist of items can be helpful, to prevent mistakes and ensure all property is accounted for.

Company records also need to be updated to account for the departure of the employee. The individual needs to be removed from payroll and internal directories and their access to company networks revoked.

The remaining workforce must be informed of the termination and changes to the structure or workload of the team. This can be a tricky task and should be communicated in a professional yet sensitive manner, addressing any concerns.

Finally, it is beneficial for the company to review the entire termination process to reflect upon, learn and improve employment processes, whilst ensuring compliance with changing legal requirements in New York.

Legal Considerations During Termination in New York

  • New York Human Rights Law (NYHRL): The NYHRL prohibits the discriminatory termination of employees. Under this law, protected characteristics include race, religion, disability, nationality, sexual orientation, gender identity, age and others. Violations of this law can lead to wrongful termination claims, costly litigation, penalties, damages and a negative public image. To mitigate against legal proceedings, employers are recommended to keep thorough documentation and evidence of lawful termination reasons.
  • The New York State WARN Act: The New York State WARN Act requires employers with 50 or more full-time employees to provide notice 90 days before reduction events such as mass layoffs, plant closures or relocation. The employer must provide notice too all affected employees, employee representatives, the Local Workforce Development Board (LWDB), the chief elected official of local government where the site is located, the school district or districts where the site of employment is located and to all emergency services that support the area where the site is located. If an employer violates this Act, they will be required to pay back wages and employee benefits and face civil penalties.
  • New York Labor Law 191: This labor law states that employers are required to deliver the final paycheck to a terminated employee by the next regular payday, at the latest. At the employee’s request, the paycheck must be sent by mail. The paycheck must include all owed wages, unused paid vacation time and commissions, unless the employment contract or company policies state otherwise. Labor law 191 applies to all departing employees, including those who have been fired, laid off or resigned.
  • New York Labor Law Section 740: Section 740 of the New York Labor Laws, prohibits employers from terminating an employee for lawfully raising concerns about illegal activity of the employer which could pose a threat to the safety and health of the public. It is also forbidden to terminate employees who refuse to participate in unlawful activity or those who assist investigations into such conduct. Employers must be aware that it is a violation of the law to fire an employee for blowing the whistle and this can result in legal action. Employers found to have violated employee rights will be required to reinstate the employee, provide compensation for lost wages and benefits and pay the legal fees and costs.

Bonus: Best Practices for Reducing Litigation Risks in New York

  • Clear and Consistent Policies: Employers should establish clear and consistent policies for employee terminations. These policies need to comply with State laws and should cover discrimination, harassment, employee misconduct and poor performance. It is crucial to regularly update company policies as laws can change. It is important to communicate policies to all employees to ensure that everyone is aware of requirements.
  • Thorough Documentation: It is crucial to have detailed records of processes such as performance reviews, warnings and relevant correspondence. Documentation should be factual, unbiased, and consistent. Proper documentation can be invaluable during legal challenges as it can be used to show lawful reasons for termination.
  • Training and Education: Implementing regular training for all staff is another great method to mitigate litigation. They should be educated about employment and workplace laws, policies, and procedures, including discrimination, harassment and employee rights. Educating employees can prove helpful in preventing the occurrence of employment violations. It can also bolster the reputation of a company by demonstrating a commitment to formulating a respectful workplace.
  • Fair and Transparent Disciplinary Actions: Disciplinary actions for poor performance and misconduct must be fair, objective, and based on properly documented evidence. Company policies should outline a consistent disciplinary process that is transparent and applicable to all employees. This ensures equity within an organisation.
  • Consult Legal Experts:  Consultation with legal counsel on a regular basis is necessary for remaining up to date with employment laws in New York. Legal counsel can provide invaluable insights and assist in navigating complex employment termination cases, preventing legal consequences.
  • Proper Handling of Terminations: It is essential that employee terminations are handled with care and respect and in full compliance with the law in New York. A thorough review of the reasons for termination should be conducted prior to the process being carried out. In addition, the termination meeting should be held in a private setting with a HR representative present and conducted in a professional manner. These methods can help reduce misunderstandings during the process and reduce litigation risks.
  • Exit Interviews: A properly conducted exit interviews can reveal important insights such as problems with working practices. The information gathered should be used to improve practices in a company and create a better working environment.

Final Thoughts

The process of terminating employees in New York can prove challenging. It is imperative that employers approach the situation appropriately and are thoroughly prepared with documentation to show lawful reasons for termination and that the process was handled with respect and fairness. All actions must adhere to company policies and state and federal laws to ensure the legality of the employee termination. Understanding the legal framework for terminations and handling the process with integrity and respect throughout, helps foster a positive work environment and minimise the risk of legal repercussions.

Important Cautionary Note

This content is provided for informational purposes only. While we make every effort to ensure the accuracy of the information presented, we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors or omissions. Users are advised to independently verify any critical information and should not solely rely on the content provided.